Best Ways to Exchange or Sell Unwanted Gift Cards

Advertiser Disclosure: At Slickdeals, we work hard to find the best deals. Some products in our articles are from partners who may provide us with compensation, but this doesn’t change our opinions. Our editors strive to ensure that the information in this article is accurate as of the date published, but please keep in mind that offers can change. We encourage you to verify all terms and conditions of any product before you apply.

Gift cards can make excellent presents for hard-to-please loved ones and savvy shoppers alike. But sometimes you’re left with a bunch of cards you know you won’t use. If you find yourself on the receiving end of a gift that’s just not for you, gift card exchange services are the perfect solution. Why regift if you can exchange your egift or physical gift card for most, if not all of its full value?
Several sites let you sell unused gift cards for cash or trade them for ones you actually want, often at a friendly discount. They all have different benefits, so really, it just depends on your preferences. It’s the gift that keeps on giving.
We’re comparing a few of the most popular gift card exchange sites, as well as providing sample payouts for some of the most resold cards from last year.

Where to Sell Gift Cards Online

1. Gift Card Granny

Primary Benefit: Huge Selection

• Range: Unlimited
• Up to 92% Return Rate
• Compares Payout Amounts From Various Gift Card Exchanges
• Payment Issued Via Direct Deposit, PayPal, or Check

Visit Gift Card Granny

The cool thing about Gift Card Granny is that the site shows you multiple offers from different gift card marketplaces — and it has an incredible selection if you’re looking to buy gift cards at a discount.
You can choose to either accept an offer or list your card for the desired price. Need money today? The site even lets you search for gift card exchanges near you so you can sell physical cards and get paid instantly.
Sample Payouts for $100 Gift Cards

• iTunes Gift Card = $75.58
• Walmart Gift Card = $90
• Best Buy Gift Card = $88.50
• Target Gift Card = $86

2. Cardpool

Primary Benefit: High Payouts

• Range: $25 to $1,000
• Up to 92% Return Rate
• Payment Issued Via Check
• Offers Amazon Gift Cards

Visit Cardpool

At Cardpool, you can choose between selling your card for cold, hard cash — or you can earn 6% more if you exchange it for an Amazon store credit instead. You can also get a bit more money if you list your gift card in the Cardpool buyer marketplace.
For some gift cards, this increases the payout by 30 cents. For others, it increases it by $5 or more. Cardpool has some of the highest payouts among online gift card exchanges, and it boasts an impressive A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
Sample Payouts for $100 Gift Cards

• iTunes Gift Card = $79 (or $84 Amazon Gift Card)
• Walmart Gift Card = $89 (or $94.34 Amazon Gift Card)
• Best Buy Gift Card = $88.50 (or $93.81 Amazon Gift Card)
• Target Gift Card = $81 (or $85.86 Amazon Gift Card)

3. Raise

Primary Benefit: Easy-to-Use Site

• Range: $5 to $2,000
• Up to 85% Return Rate
• You Set the Selling Price
• Payment Issued Via Direct Deposit, PayPal, or Check

Visit Raise

With more than two million buyers and sellers and a huge assortment of accepted brands, the Raise marketplace is a particularly great site to list gift cards and e-gifts from lesser-known stores. You can sell them for cash at your preferred price, and you’ll receive your money as soon as the gift card sells.
Raise also offers customers a one-year money-back guarantee on gift card purchases, which is great for careful shoppers. Keep in mind that Raise only accepts specific cards (like iTunes) from select stores, and trades aren’t an option. The site deducts a 15% listing fee once the exchange has been completed, hence the lower return rate.
Sample Payouts for $100 Gift Cards

• Walmart Gift Card = $84.34
• Best Buy Gift Card = $83.82
• Target Gift Card = $83.83

4. CardCash

Primary Benefit: Trades Earn Up to 13.5% More

• Range: $1 and up
• Up to 92% Return Rate
• Payment Issued Via Direct Deposit, PayPal, or Check
• Offers Amazon Gift Cards

Visit CardCash

Much Like Cardpool, CardCash lets you choose between an instant pay out or a gift card trade-in worth up to 13.5% more. Unlike Cardpool, however, you’re not limited to Amazon gift cards alone.
Other card trade-in retailers include AMC Theatres, Bass Pro Shops, Bed Bath & Beyond, CVS, eBay, Fanatics, GameStop, Hotels.com, and Overstock. CardCash also has some of the fastest pay outs around (generally within one to two business days).
Sample Payouts for $100 Gift Cards

• iTunes Gift Card = $66 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $74.91)
• Walmart Gift Card = $89 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $101.02)
• Best Buy Gift Card = $87 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $98)
• Target Gift Card = $82.15 (or a Gift Card Trade worth up to $93)

Read Next: 

• Where to Find AirPods Pro on Sale
• The Best Disney+ Subscription Deals
• Current Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Deals

Images courtesy of Gift Card Granny, Cardpool, Raise, and CardCash.